• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza - Authentic Shelton Pizzas, Fresh Pasta & Cozy Ambiance

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza in Shelton, CT, is a true neighborhood gem delivering authentic Italian flavors with a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Known for its excellent crust and flavorful toppings, standout dishes include their perfectly cooked pizzas—like the Broccoli Rabe and Sausage White—and rich vodka pasta. The fresh salads and savory wings highlight the diverse menu, while their stuffed breads offer delightful indulgence. Despite some need for clearer signage, the spacious dining area and separate take-out entrance make visits seamless. Friendly staff enhance the welcoming vibe. Antonio’s commitment to quality Italian fare makes it a top pick for locals craving genuine, satisfying pizza experiences.

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza at a glance

  • Address 376 River Rd, Shelton, CT 06484, United States
  • Phone +1 203-924-7499
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant , Meal delivery .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Noemi Crespo Rice
4

Tried Antonio's for the first time via take out. Staff are super nice. Restaurant is in great area, ample parking. Signage is confusing bc it has wrong name so I drove by twice. Salad was excellent and so fresh! Very Tasty vodka pasta. My mom loved her wings. Pizza was good, a bit on dryer side for me. Excellent crust. Signage needs some improvement to help find location.

Annie M
5

We haven't had Antonio's in a while and was craving pizza. We order two small pizzas (Broccoli Rabe and Sausage White and Polio Bianco pizza with chicken) both were absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. When you walk in, you're immediately greeted by staff. I waited a minute for my order because the cashier was finishing up with a delivery order that was heading out. We will definitely ordering again!

Andrew Vincent
5

Antonio's are in a New location . They are in the old CARMINES, (DiMairo's Dairy Bar,), building. It is next to The Riverview Funeral Home on River Road, (Rt.110), in Shelton. The New restaurant is called RITROVO, while ANTONIO'S PIZZA is in the Side Entrance. They are Both run by Antonio, but they are two separate entities in the same cozy and comfortable building. The Dining Room is spacious and there is a separate Entrance for Antonio's Take-Out. This way you don't need to walk through the Dining Room and/or Bar. Very well thought out. Also, Parking is Plentiful!! This place is Highly Recommended!! I have NEVER left disappointed!!

Sandra Michele
5

This Italian restaurant is a hidden gem!!!! Well worth the trip to Shelton!!!The pizza, their stuffed breads, the pasta, and all of their selections make for the best dining in the area!!!! I had the pizza special with sausage, fresh garlic and broccoli rabe and it was fantastic!!!!! I also tried their stuffed breads which were also fantastic!!!!!Oh and the prices are fair and reasonable as well!!!!Definately try this place!!!!! Update I was very disappointed with our broccoli rabe pizza. It came burnt and like a cracker. Definitely over cooked!!! I had asked for it crisp but not like a cracker. Never ask for their pizza crisp because all their food is cooked perfect or you will end up with what we got. The girl never asked if we liked it, I think she already knew, and when I told her she walked away. I told them they do not care and they never offered to do anything. We were good sports and ate it anyway but anywhere else I would have sent it back. Was not acceptable because of this.

Christopher
5

Excellent!! Got pizza and chicken salad for take out. It was my first time and it was so yummy. I always got the menus in the mail but for the life of me couldn't find the old location. Sooo happy with the new location and it has a great atmosphere. Right around the corner from me. They had the pizza oven right by the door to see. Will be back thank you!

Anthony Torraco
5

Check out Antonio’s pizza at 376 River Rd Shelton CT 06484 Ask for the Antonio’s supreme pizza it is delicious!!! I highly recommend them

k c
5

Stopped in here after a long day of work and craving a stuffed bread or Stromboli for days. I read the reviews before hand and am NOT disappointed. This is probably THE BEST stuffed bread I've ever had! That cheese pull is amazing! And the sauce is delicious. Only thing I'd add is more pepperoni. I definitely recommend it if you're looking for a new place to eat. I'm a SUPER picky eater.

Location

  • Antonio's Italian Style Pizza
    Antonio's Italian Style Pizza
    376 River Rd, Shelton, CT 06484, United States Hotline: +1 203-924-7499

Antonio's Italian Style Pizza, nestled in Shelton, CT, offers a genuine taste of Italy with a focus on quality and tradition. Located conveniently at 376 River Rd, this pizzeria stands out not just for its flavorful dishes but also for its thoughtful layout and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant shares its cozy building with Ritrovo, another Antonio-owned establishment, yet maintains its own separate entrance and take-out service, making visits smooth and comfortable.

What truly shines at Antonio's is their dedication to authentic Italian flavors combined with a homely touch. Customers rave about their expertly crafted pizzas, especially unique varieties like the Broccoli Rabe and Sausage White and Pollo Bianco pizza with chicken. The crust deserves special mention—crispy, well-seasoned, and baked to perfection, capturing that classic Italian pizza texture that pizza lovers seek. Although some have found the pizza on the drier side or occasionally overcooked when asked crispy, the overall craftsmanship is undeniable.

Beyond pizza, Antonio's excels with fresh salads that balance vibrant ingredients and satisfying textures, highlighted by praises of the chicken salad and freshly made greens. Their pasta dishes, like the tasteful vodka pasta, deliver rich, comforting flavors reflective of traditional Italian cooking. Not to be overlooked are the stuffed breads, which have earned accolades for their perfect dough and generous fillings.

The staff at Antonio's enhance the experience with friendly, attentive service that makes guests feel welcomed from the moment they arrive. While there has been some confusion around signage and location—due to shared premises with Ritrovo—the ample parking and well-planned separate take-out entrance help ease the visit.

In all, Antonio’s Italian Style Pizza is a commendable spot for anyone craving authentic Italian fare with a laid-back, inviting setting. The blend of fresh ingredients, strong flavors, and heartfelt preparation makes Antonio's a hidden gem in the Shelton dining scene—certainly worth the trip and a repeat visit.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards